The 2017 Tubbs Fire, 2018 Camp Fire, 2018 Woolsey Fire, and the 2025 Palisades and Eaton fires collectively triggered the most significant restructuring of California homeowner insurance in a generation. WUI properties, particularly VHFHSZ properties, are at the center of that restructuring.
What carriers have changed
- Non-renewals. Many California admitted carriers have non-renewed existing policies on VHFHSZ properties at the end of the policy term. The California Department of Insurance has issued moratoriums periodically (most recently following the 2025 fires) but the underlying underwriting tightening continues.
- New-policy refusal. Carriers that are still writing in California often refuse to write new policies in VHFHSZ entirely.
- Defensible space verification. Many carriers now require a defensible space inspection (Zones 0, 1, 2) as a condition of policy issuance.
- Home hardening verification. Some carriers require AB 38-style home hardening features (ember-resistant vents, Class A roof, non-combustible siding) as a condition of policy issuance or favorable pricing.
- Structural classification. Non-combustible structural classification (steel frame) is increasingly either required or rewarded with significantly lower premiums.
The California FAIR Plan
The California FAIR Plan is the state's insurer of last resort. Many WUI property owners who cannot obtain coverage in the admitted market now hold FAIR Plan dwelling policies, often supplemented with a difference-in-conditions (DIC) policy from a surplus-lines carrier to cover the gaps the FAIR Plan does not address (personal liability, contents above the FAIR Plan limit, etc.). FAIR Plan premiums are materially higher than admitted market premiums and coverage is limited.
How steel frame changes the equation
Non-combustible structural classification, established through documentation of steel-frame construction (mill certifications, structural drawings, AISI S100 compliance), is one of the few moves a homeowner can make that materially improves their position with both admitted carriers and FAIR Plan supplemental insurers. For the detailed analysis, see our insurance savings guide.
Sources for this section
California Department of Insurance (CDI) · California FAIR Plan Association · California Insurance Code (multiple sections) · California Insurance Commissioner non-renewal moratorium orders (2025) · AB 38 (2019)